NYCFC have dominated the historical head-to-head, winning eight of 13 encounters with Inter Miami, who have only managed one victory. In their latest meeting on February 22, 2025, the teams drew 2-2. Currently, NYCFC ride a three-game winning streak, most recently defeating Charlotte FC 2-0, with Alonso Martínez scoring twice from the penalty spot. Martínez, now at 17 goals this season, is a key figure for Pascal Jansen’s side, who have won four of their last five matches.
Inter Miami, meanwhile, return Suárez from suspension as they aim to overtake NYCFC in the Eastern Conference standings. Messi remains in contention for the MLS Golden Boot, tied with LAFC’s Denis Bouanga at 22 goals. The Herons’ last two league outings included a 3-2 win over D.C. United and a 3-1 victory against Seattle Sounders, but they also suffered a 3-0 loss to Charlotte FC earlier in September. With games in hand, Miami can afford a draw but will push for a win to improve their playoff seeding.
The predicted lineups reflect both squads’ attacking intent. NYCFC are expected to start Matt Freese in goal, with Martínez and Julián Fernández leading the attack. For Inter Miami, Messi, Suárez, and Tadeo Allende form the front three, while Jordi Alba returns to his natural left-back position.
Playoff scenarios heighten the stakes: a draw guarantees Miami a playoff spot, though they would remain fifth, just behind NYCFC and Charlotte FC. Both teams are motivated by more than just qualification—NYCFC seek home-field advantage in the playoffs, while Inter Miami, under the spotlight with Messi’s reported contract extension negotiations (Lionel Messi), aim to finish the regular season on a high.
Given the teams’ recent forms and playoff urgency, another high-scoring encounter is likely. The last time Inter Miami defeated NYCFC was in August 2022, underscoring the challenge ahead.
Score Prediction: NYCFC 2–2 Inter Miami.
For more details, see the full preview on Sports Illustrated: NYCFC vs. Inter Miami Preview and playoff scenarios via USA TODAY: Inter Miami MLS playoff scenarios.